Lumines: Electronic Symphony is an interesting proposition for a game. There is some major fun to be had with the gameplay in Lumines. There is also some major yawns to be had after a while. Being that the major “meat” to Lumines is a puzzle game, the value proposition is a more hefty consideration than normal.
The basics behind any Lumines game is erasing blocks while pretty cool music plays in the background in accordance to your performance. Blocks come down in sets of 4 smaller blocks of two different colors. When four blocks of the same color are combined they are erased by the Timing Line. You can get bonuses by erasing four or more squares each time the line passes. The line and rate of descent of the blocks will vary with each new song, keeping you on your toes.
The often frantic nature of the gameplay mixed with some stellar music makes Lumines really addictive. A couple of times I looked at the timer to see that I had been playing for over two hours. After a couple of playthroughs I had learned what to do with just about every block scenario. This led to a sort of lethargy where the gameplay was less about the puzzle and more like a “stimuli, response” exercise. “In this scenario with this block drop it here, in this scenario do this, and now this block optimally goes here.”
Lumines tries to offer an inkling of replay value with a leveling system. Every block you clear is worth some XP and once you level up you receive more avatars and unlock some more songs. This feature could quite possibly keep you playing for a while as long as you never connect to another on of the features, the World Block. The World Block is a neat idea where everyone that is playing Lumines is erasing a huge cube of blocks. It really is fun to see what you contributed and how much is need to erase it. The problem is that once the World Block is erased you receive a huge XP bonus. SO huge in fact that I had hit the level 50 cap after only two World Blocks had been erased. Both systems, levels and World Block, are great by themselves but they break one another when used in tandem.
Once you have beaten the main “Journey” mode you will have most of the songs you could want to play. You can then take these songs and create a playlist of your favorite skins and tracks with them. There are just a little over twenty of them, some great and some not so great. The music really is a matter of personal taste though but suffice it to say if you like zen techno then you should be happy. My one real issue is that the score you get in playlist mode is never recorded. I can understand that it could break the game to put on an easy playlist and loop it to obliterate the score. On the flip side I do not like some of the songs in the Journey mode. Having no score tracking makes this normally fun mode feel like a huge waste of time since none of your friends will see it.
There are a few other modes to play as well. For those of you that wish to push your skills there is a “Master” mode that throws blocks at you super quickly. There is a duel mode which pits you against another player. Duel mode is Ad Hoc only, because I guess the internet just is not powerful enough to handle blocks yet. Lastly there is a time attack mode, pretty self explanatory. Time attack really boils down to just the puzzle solving without any of the catchy music that Lumines it known for.
If you are starting to see a trend here you are not crazy. Lumines is a great puzzle game by itself but that is not enough to keep it alive. Taking out score tracking from almost every mode and breaking the level system really soured my experience. I wish that there was more to this game because as it stands Lumines has almost no replay value. This is not good for a puzzle game that needs both great gameplay and replay value and can not survive without both.
I really had a blast with Lumines: Electronic Symphony for about the first week. After that initial week the gloss came off and the game showed it’s true colors. Underneath all that glam is a puzzle game with music, nothing more. It is a good puzzle game and it is good music but for 40$ the value is a little sketchy. If you love Lumines or puzzle games in general then get this game. For everyone else, you could pass over this game and not really miss much.





